Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania — A letter written by a concerned parent to the Cumberland Valley School District seeks the release of information.
The letter states:
Cumberland Valley School District
6746 Carlisle Pike
Mechanicsburg, PA 17050August 16, 2026
To the School Board Directors of Cumberland Valley School District:
I am writing to ask why Cumberland Valley School District continues to oppose the release of a police report and security footage concerning an incident involving “The Big Red Truck.”
Unless the Cumberland Valley Police Department has decided to reopen the matter and pursue criminal charges against the driver, I do not understand why these records cannot be released. I was previously told by the responding officer that the video and police report would be available. Yet the District’s Right-to-Know office and its solicitor, Johnson & Duffie, appear to be contesting the release of these records.
That raises serious questions. Is there something incriminating in the video? Is the District withholding the footage because the person driving the truck is a school board member? I am asking these questions because I was directly involved in the incident, and I have a legitimate interest in knowing how many inches that vehicle came to making contact with me in an otherwise empty parking lot. I know what I witnessed that day, but I would like to see the actual video for myself.
By continuing to fight the release of this information, the District creates the appearance that there is something it does not want the public to see. If there is a legitimate legal reason the records cannot be released, I believe taxpayers deserve a clear explanation of that reason.
I also question the amount of taxpayer money being spent on legal representation in Right-to-Know matters. Some members of this board recently went to the state Capitol seeking additional state funding, and state legislators responded by providing additional resources. Are those legislators aware of how much Cumberland Valley School District is spending on legal services to oppose citizens seeking access to public records?
These are taxpayer-funded resources. Citizens should be able to ask reasonable questions and obtain public records without feeling that the District will use its legal resources to make access unnecessarily difficult.
I am also concerned about the message this situation sends to members of the community. If citizens cannot obtain a police report and security footage concerning an incident occurring on school property, they may reasonably question whether reporting an incident through the District is the best option. Transparency and public confidence depend on citizens believing that records will be handled openly and appropriately.
I am therefore asking the School Board to reconsider its position and release the police report and security footage, provided there is no legitimate legal basis preventing their disclosure. Because the board has not responded to my emails on this subject, I am forced to do an open letter for the public to see.
If the District believes these records are exempt from disclosure, please explain specifically what legal exemption applies and why. I would also ask the Board to explain to taxpayers how much the District has wasted on legal fees associated with opposing the release of these records and other Right-to-Know requests.
The public deserves transparency. If there is nothing improper about the incident or the records, releasing them should help resolve questions rather than create additional suspicion.
Will this Board reverse course and demonstrate a genuine commitment to transparency, or will it continue wasting taxpayer-funded resources fighting citizens who are seeking access to public records?
I respectfully ask you to release the video and police report, or provide the public with a specific and transparent explanation of why you will not.
Sincerely,
Jason Snyder
Concerned Citizen of Cumberland Valley School District
Harrisburg100 
Is “Bacon Dunn” coming to Dr. Verber’s 9/11 Hotdog Celebration Party?
LikeLike
cV CuReS should run a fund raiser for Dr. Kitty Litter’s CV Furry Club and have Bacon Dunn sit in a dunk tank. $1000s could be raised!
LikeLike
Heck, put Superintendent Blanchard in a dunk tank to raise money for paying Johnson & Duffie legal bills for suppressing Nestor’s BRT documents!
LikeLike
Someone should call Chris Hansen to investigate Dr. Brian Litterbox Allen and his furry clubs for minors.
LikeLike
Bud “Curmudgeon” Shaffner and his “Bookkeeper” Marty Carreras have volunteered to help raise money for their lawsuits legal defense….old Marty still faces an active Federal Fraud Count….
He was only running for Hampden CP bc he thought it paid a salary….
LikeLike
They still have cash in the Capone safe.
LikeLike
CV Superintendent Blanchard could always ask Bud “Capone” Shaffner for some of that cash in those DE and FL waterfront mansion safes! Marty “Bookkeeper” Carreras has their combos!
LikeLike
Everyone knows that Board Pres Nestor hauled both of Shaffner’s safes to DE and FL in her Big Red Truck (before she started using it as a weapon against parents)!
LikeLike
What horrible people. It is disgusting that Dr Michael Verber and his political apparatus CV CUReS is openly celebrating the death of 3000 Americans in the worst terrorist attack on American soil. Maybe CV CUReS should be listed as a terror organization.
LikeLike
cV CUres is a disgrace. Their true colors are showing! This is what Michelle Nestor, Mike O’Brien, Brian Allen, Asheleigh Forsburg, and PA State REP Tomas Kutz believe in and openly support. I hope PA residents are watching.
LikeLike
Michelle Nestor loves the publicity! Several CV parents saw her at the Dodge Truck dealership on the Pike looking at new Big Red Truck replacement! They heard her asking salesman for two extra option….an extra re-enforced grill for striking “things”….and a beer cooler in the console.
LikeLike
Why do they hate America so much?
LikeLike
I can’t believe that Mike and his CV Cures group have gone this far with the TDS and hate. I’ve gone from losing respect for him to losing the desire to ever talk to him again. He is filled with so much hate and anger. What a sad man.
LikeLike
A wiener swallowing contest? Fitting.
LikeLike
Who can swallow the most? Dr Hotdog Verber, President Michelle Nestor, Dr Kitty Litter Allen, or Zorro?
LikeLike
Given her proclivity to liberal politics, how could Heather Dunn turn down the opportunity to stuff her face while celebrating a terrorist attack on America.
LikeLike
The two main reasons that Dr Mike Verber loves her company so much. They share the exact same interests.
LikeLike
Are the football scandals about the Peruvian marching powder or the racism or the illegal recruitment?
LikeLike
It gets so much worse than that. Buckle up buttercup. The pain is about to begin. The legal system is a slow process but justice will prevail.
LikeLike
I wouldn’t accept a few resignations after what they’ve done. I want to see mass firings and criminal investigations opened up.
LikeLike
Is Verber and his cv cures group seriously celebrating the anniversary of the 9/11 terror attacks with a hotdog party? WTF? Seriously what in the actual F**k?
LikeLike
Wait until you find out what Dr Brian kitty litter Allen celebrates. It will make you sick.
LikeLike
That guy is disgusting. He shouldn’t be within a mile of any child.
LikeLike
CV Athletic Director Mike Craig and his Asst Athletic Director Darnell Stanford are both running scared. They know they broke PA laws, violated PIAA and CV policies, and attempted to screw over several athletes that complained.
And they know that Nestor and Blanchard can’t save them…..since they have their own legal problems.
LikeLike
Darnell Stanford actually thinks he will be anointed as Mike Craig’s replacement when Craig retires….or if forced to retire early due to the numerous scandals!
Parents and residents will find out the truth of how BOTH Craig and Stanford DO NOT care about CV students….only their reputations that are about to be tarnished due to the current and imminent legal actions that will drop on them!
Stanford should be trying to secure another job outside the Harrisburg Region before it’s too late.
LikeLike
How many lawsuits will Dr Mark Blanchard be named in before 2027?
LikeLike
Someone should start a pool.
LikeLike
CV Athletic Director Mike Craig NOW letting any athlete transfer from CV that wants to since he, Blanchard, and Andrechik in deep PIAA and legal sh&t about what they did trying to screw over three football players who transferred.
LikeLike
So he was heavy handed before, gaming the system for his personal and professional gain, and now out of fear of what’s coming, now that he has been caught red handed, he stopped doing his job and anything goes.
LikeLike
Dr. Robyn Euker thought she was skirting legal trouble by resigning as Asst Superintendent and hiding in her old job. But NO USE…as one of the “Judas Letter” 10,,,,she is still smack dab in the middle of legal, ethical, and discrimination issues!
….and Blanchard and Nestor won’t be able to protect her…..
LikeLike
Dr Push Euker is rightfully nervous about what is coming.
LikeLike
The CV administration and board majority seem to be quickly forming a “circular firing squad” with everyone doing whatever they have to to protect themselves…even if it means throwing someone under the bus….
The ONLY WINNER….Johnson & Duffie Law Firm making HUGE coin off of the legal woes of CV….Mike Cassidy has the board majority snowed-over while being Superintendent Blanchard lap dog….
LikeLike
A football parent in the know just let our FB private group know that huge stuff coming down from the PIAA on CV. Don’t know yet how it will affect this season. I’m even hearing rumors about the troubles maybe affecting CV’s wins last year.
Appreciate any insight on this from anyone….thanks.
LikeLike
It has to be from the illegal stuff Craig did. Dr Blanchard and President Michelle Nestor thought they had it covered up but it is all coming out. Including the attempt to cover these issues up.
LikeLike
CV Mike Craig and Darnell Stanford…..CAUGHT!!!! …..along with Josh Oswalt!
LikeLike
Craig & Stanford days in their jobs appear to ne numbered!
LikeLike
Are we just talking firings or are we talking arrests?
LikeLike
CV Football parents talking about Michelle Nestor taking over coaching CV’s Varsity Football Team….I hope not! PIAA does not allow drinking on the sidelines!
LikeLike
She would just drive her truck over the other team for a touchdown.
LikeLike
You’re right! At least the BRT would be useful!
LikeLike
The PIAA needs to institute a breathalyzer rule if she becomes coach.
LikeLike
CV Superintendent Mark Blanchard having a difficult time holding scandals together….he’s running out of fingers and toes in the CV Dike!
LikeLike
New to this blog. Question: How much money has been paid to the Johnson Duffie Law Firm to defend CV Athletic scandals like Cheerleading, Football, Girls Wrestling, Boosters, XXXXXX, XXXXXX….????
LikeLike
Deep six figures had been wasted to protect the Shaffners, Craig, Stanford….and School Director and Athletic Chair Mike “Shaffner 2.0” O’Brien….who has done nothing except suppress free speech when not in his tanning booth.
LikeLike
He hasn’t done nothing, just ask his trainer.
LikeLike
How many tens of thousands have they wasted on blocking legal RTK requests? They don’t care that they keep losing. This is a stall tactic. Will the judge throw the book at CV and Johnson and Duffie for this very dirty and unethical tactic?
LikeLike
Is that legal?
LikeLike
So a dirty ambulance chasing attorney decides to keep the work going and extra billing the district. So the idiots on the board let the crooks at the law firm decide how to waste taxpayer money? It’s like letting the fox guard the hen house.
LikeLike
I think Dr. Robyn “Judas” Euker needs to start looking for a new job in another part of Pennsylvania.
LikeLike
You can put Dr. Mark “Judas” Blanchard as a reference though (before he’s sanctioned and/or fired)…….
LikeLike
I think that Jerry Sandusky non profit has an opening. That is totally in her wheelhouse and right up her alley. She would love that.
LikeLike
Don’t forget about Oswalt getting fired!
LikeLike
It better include the rest of CV involved in the collusion to cover up these illegal acts.
LikeLike
Just like criminal syndicates, those involved in criminal activities at CV believe their lawyers can protect them and bury the truth.
LikeLike
CV Board President Michelle Nestor (same Michelle Nestor as the Death Race 2026 Big Red Truck fame) is also embroiled in a massive scandal within her political county party. As expected, Mrs. Nested cheated her way to being elected in a leadership position to attempt to salvage her damaged and declining political career.
Just like at CVSD, Mrs. Nestor is unable to suppress being exposed….and running people over in her Big Red Truck is not an option this time!
Her supporters are running for the hills since she is radioactive and toxic to associate with her.
LikeLike
CV Board President Michelle Nestor still out in town in her Big Red Truck….looking for more parents she doesn’t like?
LikeLike
….or is she headed again to Johnny Joe’s for 2 for 1 well drinks before she gets on top of bar and grinds for the crowd again!
LikeLike
Then off to the CV high school showers for another shower incident.
LikeLike
CV parents were safe yesterday since Nestor and her Big Red Truck were at Carlisle game. She nearly missed 3 cars on Simpson Ferry racing back to catch several nightcaps at Johnny Joe’s! …..before ending the night at Gilligan’s were her rage-drinking buddy Lou Capozzi!
LikeLike
My friend saw Michelle Nestor zooming around in her Big Red Truck…public enemy list in one hand and her makeup compact in the other! What a disgraceful example for our children.
LikeLike
We all know it was a wine bottle in one hand while texting with her other hand and steering with her knees.
LikeLike
How can she look for parents when she is seeing double?
LikeLike
CV Superintendent Mark Blanchard continues to DENY DENY DENY right to know requests and spends $1000s to appeal in court instead of providing the public records he’s intentionally hiding. And who let’s him do this – Michelle “Big Red Truck” Nestor, Elected Democrat Jevon Ford, Mike “Shaffner 2.0” O’Brien, Dr. Brian “Kitty Litter” Allen, and Asheleigh “Mike Verber owns me” Forsburg……
Selling out one’s integrity is not a good thing….
LikeLike
The slush fund cv cUrES only wants those they can leverage easily. Those with integrity need not apply.
LikeLike
Dunn…Dunn, Dunn, Dunn…Dunn…..
Where is Heather “bacon” Dunn hiding these days? She used to shuffle up to the podium and angrily scream that all these people trying to expose CV….and “tear down Dr. Blanchard” was nothing….and RIDICULOUS! Really…seems like Bacon Dunn is finally thrown in the towel and realized her and RINO Greg Rausch’s tenue as Board Presidents is one of the BIGGEST reasons the district is in so much trouble!
LikeLike
Come on….maybe if that Bacon Dunn girl spent more time doing board oversight versus living at the “Ole Country Buffet”, CV might be in better shape!
LikeLike
You’re wrong. I blame that angry RINO-thin-skinned Mike “The Grinch” Gossert and Bud “Curmudgeon” Shaffner…with assistance from Marty “The Cappone Book keeper” Carreras for the problems!
LikeLike
Heather….stop posting comments saying it’s Bud and me to blame!
LikeLike
It is totally yours and Bud’s fault, otherwise Mike Verber and Superintendent Mark Blanchard wouldn’t call me all the time to tell them what to do and say.
LikeLike
Mike Verber and Heather Dunn were seen earlier this week at that all you can eat sushi place by the movie theater on Simpson Ferry. Some CV parents say them go back for 6 rounds of seconds over a two hour troughing session scheming what they wanted to direct Superintendent Mark Blanchard to do and say. Really “distasteful” in many ways….
LikeLike
The word hangry really takes its true form when discussing those two.
LikeLike
A new low in distasteful. A dirty sanchez while in line for the buffet. Zero class.
LikeLike
Greg and I did everything possible to withhold emails and work around those trouble makers on the board. We successfully locked them out. Unfortunately, we were now left with a total idiot running the board. There’s a reason it took Michelle 10 years to become board president….and I use that title quite loosely.
LikeLike
Funny that you chose the term loosely. That is another fitting term for the idiot.
LikeLike
Michelle Nestor was too stupid to come up with the idea of Mike Cassidy just deny everything and appeal everything to courts no matter what it costs. We tell the public whatever we want on budget and them fudge the numbers with mystery revenue appearing out of nowhere during the summer when the board is out. It’s been working for years, and the public is too ignorant to figure it out!
LikeLike
What I didn’t count on that f’ing things up right now is Michelle Nestor having one of her rage fits and trying to run over one of her enemies in broad daylight. At least she’s got Blanchard and Cassidy working for her to suppress the release of the video and police report. I’ll give her credit for doing that.
LikeLike
She owns them, they own her. Quid pro quo. In political corruption circles, quid pro quo is as old as written history.
LikeLike
Scandals and cover-ups are all that Michelle Nestor and Mark Blanchard know. They both leaded from Bacon Dunn and RINO Rausch.
LikeLike
Definitely a quid pro quo between Blanchard, Nestor, and Cassidy…Blanchard wants to keep his job, Nestor doesn’t want to be exposed, and disgraceful Mike Cassidy only cares about keeping the Johnson & Duffie CV Solicitor’s contract and milking CV for as much money as possible with his flawed legal advice and shoddy legal work.
LikeLike
CV’s lawmakers who they all beg for money should be pissed that the money they got fof CV is now being wasted by the tens of thousands of dollars on protecting Nestor and Blanchard.
LikeLike
Don’t forget, Mike Verber’s Cv cuRse political slush fund OWNS several of our lawmakers…..starting with that sellout Thomas Kutz…who is always a guest at Verber’s hot dog parties…..like the 9-11 hotdog party Verber is having celebrating the deaths of 3000 Americans…and promoted by Michelle Nestor.
LikeLike
It’s not only embarrassing, it sounds completely unethical and very illegal.
LikeLike
Nestor, Verber, and Kutz don’t care…they are all opportunists!
LikeLike
New Week….NEW CV Scandal….stand by….
LikeLike
Porn in the classroom, the school board president aggressively driving a truck at a taxpayer, a chaperone making children pee in cups on a school bus, girls molested in front of dozens of witnesses and they all get covered up. Could a shower scandal be next?
LikeLike
….or a student and former German teacher relationship? ….and providing alcohol to minor…..and Blanchard caught lying to board about it…and THAT IS WHY Blanchard and Nestor used Cassidy to STOP providing public records to citizens bc of their scandals, cover-ups, and hiding the truth!
Question: What are they still hiding?
LikeLike
Solicitor Mike Cassidy has sold out his integrity.
LikeLike
….and all Blanchard and Nestor had to do was to follow the law, tell the truth, and do the right thing. It WAS that easy.
LikeLike
….WOW just heard about CV’s Teacher’s Union President’s wife forcing girls on a co-ed bus to dig through the garbage can to pee in a dirty coffee cup when “Cat” de La Berarra was Pres of Band Boosters and the official CV chaperone. …and what did the non-ethical Superintendent Mark Blanchard do….suspended her as a chaperone for 2 yrs…and NOW “Cat” is back chaperoning our children with the FULL backing and support of CVSD Superintendent Mark Blanchard.
Wow…selling out our children to keep Mario and the union in his back pocket.
LikeLike
Hey…I googled CV scandals in AI….yes, it’s there “Peeing in coffer cup scandal”…..now I’ve seen it all!
LikeLike
Also, when googling CV scandals….found multiple Federal Lawsuits including CV teachers hold up a picture of monkeys and telling a black student it looked like them! And school board members like that child-transition-promoter and advocate Dr. Brian Allen goes on his FB page and pontificates about what a great school district CV is….
…and what do we keep hearing from him when parents publicly challenge him….he brings up his fixation on kitty litter boxes in the schools….he’s sick!
LikeLike
***PSA- Heard there was a new book coming out in paperback during holidays “Cumberland Valley Scandals and Debauchery” ….”a history of CV coverups and collusion at the expense of the children”…..
LikeLike